Home   »  Issue Areas  »  Good Jobs & Healthcare  »  Living Wage Jobs with Healthcare ...

Sham ballot measure denounced by civic leaders

Press release and photo gallery from the event

News release: June 10, 2010
Contact: Susan Duerksen, CPI
     619-584-5744 x.64 or 619-804-1950

Deceptive ballot measure would ban living wages

City leaders warn contractor-funded initiative is "bait and switch"

San Diego elected officials, faith leaders and community leaders today denounced a misleading and destructive new ballot measure bankrolled by government contractors and developers. Several speakers called the measure "a classic bait and switch."

The initiative would overturn and ban San Diego's Living Wage Ordinance, and prohibit many other requirements on contractors. Contrary to proponents' claims, it would actually reduce transparency and accountability in city contracting, and would cost the city millions of dollars in state and federal funding.

"This measure is transparent in name only and fails to properly disclose the fact that it would eliminate the City's Living Wage Ordinance," said Councilmember Donna Frye. "Contrary to its title, it's as transparent as a brick wall."  

The six-page proposition contains a string of hidden impacts:

  • It bans San Diego's Living Wage Ordinance by prohibiting wage requirements above minimum wage
  • It prevents the City's use of state and federal funds for public works projects -- from street repair to the convention center expansion.
  • It bans requirements for local hiring and standards for contractor qualifications and safety training.
  • It bans equal benefits protections.
The measure is far from "grassroots," as claimed by Councilmember Carl DeMaio. In just the first three months, the contractors' lobby spent $161,000 on paid signature-gatherers. Voters report being misinformed and pressured to sign, and sometimes fooled by the deceptive wording.

"I deeply wish that I could take my signature back," said voter Stephanie Alaimo of Mission Hills. "I firmly support the need for a living wage in California. This initiative is ... far from transparent!"  

The ballot measure claims to implement the stalled Managed Competition program, but actually guts it and creates a new process to force privatization of public services -- with far less accountability, no oversight or cost monitoring, and more risk of corruption.  

"This ballot measure is a sham and a disgrace," said Father Tommie Jennings, of Christ the King Catholic Church.  "Our public dollars should never be used to subsidize poverty wages. This will do great harm to hard-working families in our community."

The Center on Policy Initiatives, which advocates for low- and middle-income workers, has created a committee to fight the ballot measure, called Stop the Ban of Living Wages. More information is available at www.ProtectLivingWages.org.

Speakers:

Donna Frye, San Diego City Councilmember, District 6

Marti Emerald, San Diego City Councilmember, District 7

Todd Gloria, San Diego City Councilmember, District 3

Richard Barrera, President, San Diego Unified School District

Richard Lawrence, Southeastern Economic Development Corp. and Affordable Housing Coalition

Reverend Dr. Jamie Gates, President, Interfaith Committee for Worker Justice of San Diego County (ICWJ) & Professor, Point Loma Nazarene University, Center for Justice and Reconciliation

Reverend Wayne Riggs, Pastor, Plymouth Congregational Church

Father Tommie Jennings, Pastor, Christ the King Catholic Church

Christy Figueroa, Chair, San Diego Organizing Project

Murtaza Baxamusa, PhD, Research and Policy Director, Center on Policy Initiatives

###